Explaining “why?” sometimes takes a special person. An individual’s field of study, expertise, experience, or specialization makes them capable of taking a topic and providing an encapsulating explanation. Societal cooperation’s weakness is such a topic. Thus, an expert in the field remarked as follows:
“Of course, we cannot talk about cooperation without acknowledging the flip side: cooperation is infinitely vulnerable to cheats and freeloaders that exploit the collective for their own gain. As we shall see, often these social cheats are cooperating, but in ways that impose costs on others: cooperation frequently has victims. Cancer cells cooperate with one another inside multicellular bodies, to the detriment of the sufferers. Nepotism, corruption and bribery are all forms of cooperation, occurring among a minority of individuals while imposing wider costs to society.” The Social Instinct (2021) Raihani, at P. 3.
Dr. Nichola Raihani, a psychologist and Professor of Evolution and Behaviour at University College London, provided this observation in her book- The Social Instinct (2021.) In it, she investigates the biological phenomena of cooperation.
While Dr. Raihani’s quote is not revelatory, it succinctly explains that cooperation is susceptible to many problems. Societal ills from cooperation were appreciated in antiquity; even the Torah was sensitive to cooperation’s perils. One particular Pentateuch passage concerning manna’s collection evidences the awareness.
The Omer
Cooperation’s perils were acknowledged and addressed in the Torah during the Exodus. In the Book of Exodus, God provides food-manna- for the newly freed slaves. God’s provision included a distribution plan. The Children of Israel were instructed as follows: “Collect some of it, each according to what he eats; you shall take an omer per head, the number of your persons, each for whoever is in his tent.” Exodus 16:16-17. The allotment was termed an “omer.” The passage also tells that, when the portions were measured, no one exceeded or fell short of the omer. In essence, strict controls were made to ensure that the food was equally distributed.
Even within the telling of the manna which emphasized this exactness in distribution, there were still individuals who did not listen to Moses’ instructions. Rather than eating all of the manna on the same day as instructed, some saved some of it for the morning. Exodus 16:19-20.
The Next “Why?”
Given that cooperation’s “flip side” is corruption, there is another question which must be asked: “Why do both lawmakers who legislate cooperative programs and administrators who run cooperative programs often fail in taking appropriate measures to limit it?”
Conclusion
In order to address societal ills, it is essential that clear, coherent, and meaningful explanations be provided to society. Too often, people are fully aware of many of these problems which cost society dearly. They, however, have yet to connect all the dots or lack the ability to articulate the matter in totality. In this instance, Dr. Raihani did an excellent job at addressing the flipside of cooperation. Succinct explanations often prompt additional questions.
Be well!!
Please like, follow, comment or share